You Got In-Now What? Tips for Choosing the Right College
SaveHow to make a confident college decision by focusing on fit, finances, and your future goals.
By SAGE Scholars — April 20, 2025
Spring brings blooming flowers, longer days-and big decisions for high school seniors. As college acceptance letters roll in, excitement often mixes with stress. Now comes the challenging part: choosing where to spend the next four years of your life.
This decision can feel overwhelming-and for good reason. You may still be figuring out your goals. College is a major financial investment. And for many, not getting into a first-choice school adds a layer of disappointment. But take heart-plenty of successful people, including Warren Buffett, faced rejections and still built extraordinary futures.
At SAGE Scholars, we've put together a few helpful tips to guide you through the process of finding your best-fit college.
Talk to Current Students
When visiting a college, don't just rely on brochures or campus tours. Grab lunch in a dining hall or hang out in a common space and ask a few current students what they really think about the school:
- What are their favorite (or least favorite) classes?
- How's campus life?
- What surprised them most after enrolling?
Hearing from real students gives you a more personal perspective on daily life at the school.
Compare Financial Aid Packages
College is a big investment-and every dollar counts. Take the time to compare your financial aid offers side by side. If your top-choice school offered less aid than another, don't hesitate to contact the financial aid office and ask if they can reconsider or match a more generous offer.
Tip: It never hurts to ask. Schools won't offer more unless they know your situation-and you may end up saving thousands.
Sit in on a Class
Most colleges allow prospective students to observe a class or two. This can be a great way to:
- Get a feel for the academic environment
- See how professors and students interact
- Test out the vibe of your intended major
Just remember: one class doesn't represent the entire school, but it can offer useful insight.
Explore the Surrounding Community
You won't spend all your time on campus, so think about what kind of environment makes you feel at home. While visiting:
- Check out local restaurants, parks, or shops
- See how far it is to your favorite hobbies (hiking, concerts, sports, etc.)
- Ask yourself: could I see myself living here for four years?
That said, don't base your decision solely on the town's best taco joint-but it's okay to consider how your interests fit the location.
Final Thoughts
Choosing a college is about more than prestige or name recognition. It's about finding a place where you can learn, grow, and feel supported-academically, socially, and financially. Keep asking questions. Keep comparing options. And trust that the right choice for you might not be the obvious one to anyone else.
No matter where you end up, this next chapter is full of opportunity-and your path to success is just beginning.
SAGE Scholars
At SAGE Scholars, we deeply believe in the value and quality of private higher education. Our mission is to provide access to affordable college opportunities while bringing together families, colleges & universities, and benefit providers to create college funding solutions. Since 1995, SAGE Scholars has bridged the gap between students who want a quality private college education and colleges that will work closely with member families to ensure affordability - all at no cost to the families.Articles & Advice
Featured Articles from The SAGE Scholars Benefit
Ten Minute Professor: 9 Ways to Qualify for More Merit Aid
Ten Minute Professor: A 5th Year of College Is Expensive
